We tend to think of optimism as something that happens to us—like weather. Some days we feel hopeful, some days we don’t, and we treat that internal climate as something outside our control. But the Stoics had a very different view. Hope, for them, wasn’t a mood. It wasn’t a dopamine spike or a motivational poster. It was a discipline. A practice. A choice rooted in the same place as courage: the willingness to move forward regardless of how you feel.

The modern world often looks at pessimism as realism and optimism as naïveté. But the Stoics would flip that. They believed living without rational hope is actually the foolish approach, because it assumes the future is only ever shaped by what is outside of you. A Stoic assumes the opposite: the future is constructed based on the decisions of each member of the Cosmos. If you show up with discipline and virtue, things will generally move in the direction they should—even if it’s slower than many of us would prefer.

So optimism becomes a stance, not a feeling, and that means that it’s not something we wait for; it’s something we build.

The optimism of competence

There’s a certain hope that comes from simply knowing you’re prepared. When a tug leaves the harbour, the crew might feel anxious about weather, traffic or tight channels. But if they know the vessel is maintained, the charts are correct, the safety drills have been run, and the captain is competent, that anxiety becomes manageable. It doesn’t disappear—but it becomes something you can operate through. That’s Stoic optimism. It’s the optimism that comes from competence:

I’ve trained for this. I’ve prepared for this. I’ve done the work. Whatever comes, I will meet it with strength. You can’t fake that. You can’t affirm your way into it. Only disciplined preparation generates that kind of quiet confidence.

The impediment to action advances action. - Marcus Aurelius, Meditations, 5.20

But it only advances action for someone who has put in the work. Obstacles make the prepared person better, while they are ruthless on the unprepared.

So if you want to feel more optimistic about your life, the path isn’t emotional engineering—it’s competence. Train yourself. Get stronger. Sharpen your skills. Build systems. Improve your processes. Know your craft. Optimism isn’t a feeling; it’s earned self-trust.

Repetition builds rational hope

Every rep in the gym teaches your body something. Every cold plunge teaches your mind something. Every difficult conversation you get through teaches your character something. Stoic optimism emerges through this repetition—the steady stacking of proof that you can do hard things without collapsing.

People often wait to feel ready before acting. But the Stoics would call that backwards. Readiness comes from acting. And optimism comes from seeing the evidence accumulate:

“I’ve done this before. I survived it. I learned something. I adapted.” That pattern—stress, response, growth—creates a kind of grounded hope that is much harder to shake than any emotional high.

You don’t need to feel optimistic to take action. Instead, you take action and let optimism form behind you like a wake.

Virtue as the source of true hope

But the Stoics take it deeper than competence and repetition. They root optimism in virtue.

If you act with integrity, if you aim at justice, if you keep your temperance, if you use wisdom to guide your choices—then you’ve already done what truly matters.

You’ve aligned yourself with the best part of human nature. You’ve lived “according to nature,” which, to the Stoics, means living rationally and cooperating with the world rather than fighting against it.

From that place, hope becomes rational.

If I do the right thing, consistently, then even if the outcome is rough, I’m still shaping myself into something stronger. I’m still moving forward. I’m still capable of facing tomorrow with clarity, not regret.

This is the optimism behind a mantra I’ve coined to manage such difficult times:

“I do what I think is right, and that’s enough.” That’s Stoicism in its purest form. Optimism rooted in virtue doesn’t depend on how the story turns out. It depends on how you show up to the story.

Choosing optimism daily

Here’s the real point: since optimism is a discipline, it has to be practiced like one. Make space for strategic thinking. Invest in healthy habits. Do your work with integrity. Face difficult conversations with courage. Prepare for the difficult weeks before they hit.

And when the emotional weather changes—because I can promise you that it will—it won’t matter. You’ll be able to hold a steady course because you didn’t rely on feeling hopeful to behave well. You let the discipline generate the hope.

Stoic optimism is quiet, and, therefore, often unseen. But it’s the confidence that if you commit to virtue today, tomorrow becomes something you can handle.

Not because it will be easy. But because you will be strong.

Brandon is most well-known for his podcast, The Strong Stoic Podcast , where he discusses philosophical ideas both solo and with guests. He also coaches individuals to help them be their best selves, writes articles, plays music, manages projects, and several other things.

---